THE DOCTOR AND THE SHEIKHS' DEBATE

Index

Translator's Preface .......... 7

Introduction .......... 8

Ordinance of Pilgrimage .......... 11

Day Nineteenth of Zyqadeh, Flying to Medina .......... 12

Getting Acquainted with Sheikh Ibrahim Usman (Sheikh) .......... 15

The Twentieth of Zyqadeh .......... 22

Proof of Brotherhood (Shias are Muslims) .......... 22

The one God .......... 22

The one Prophet .......... 23

The one Quran .......... 23

The one Qibla .......... 24

The one Salat (Pray) .......... 25

The one Hajj .......... 25

An Organized Discussion .......... 25

The Rules for the Debate and Discussion .......... 26

The Lack of Probity of Companions in Quran .......... 28

Differences between Companions, the Reason for their Probity .......... 32

References about the Weakness of the Hadith Regarding the Justice of Companions .......... 33

Every Day after the Morning Pray at Baqi .......... 37

Is the Prophet (s.a.w.a) Dead? .......... 38

Day Twenty First of Zyqadeh .......... 40

Accuracy Verification of the Hadith's in Sihah al Sittah .......... 41

Mote' (Concubine) and Temporary Marriage .......... 46

The 1987 Mecca Incident .......... 55

The Twenty Second of Zyqadeh .......... 57

There is No Difference between the Prophet Being Dead or Alive .......... 58

Crying for the Dead .......... 62

Blessing and Pleading to the Righteous Dead .......... 69

Pleading to Imam Bukhari's Grave .......... 70

Supplication in Shia'sm .......... 71

There are No Imprecations upon the Caliphas .......... 82

Day Twenty Third of Zyqadeh .......... 87

Continuation of Supplication in Shia'sm .......... 88

Combining the Zuhr, Asir and Maghrib, Isha Prayer .......... 105

Supplication for Repentance .......... 106

Pilgrimaging in Shia'sm and the licence Permission for Sunni to Pilgrimage .......... 109

Pilgrimaging and Its Ritual's Based on Alazhar .......... 115

The Confessions of Mohammad Ibn Abudl Wahab .......... 118

The Dynamics of Authority and Imitating in Shia'sm .......... 119

Day Twenty Fourth of Zyqadeh .......... 125

Getting Acquainted with Sheikh Hamid Al Najdi .......... 125

Debate in Sheikh Hamid's House .......... 126

Ablution in Islam .......... 133

Call for Prayer in Islam .......... 141

Amen and Takattuf (placing hand on hand) .......... 144

Loudly Reading "In the name of God the Beneficent, the Merciful" Whilst Praying

Islam and Politics .......... 180

Day Sixth of Zihijjah .......... 191

Hazrat Mahdi in Ahl Sunnat's Books .......... 191

The Age of Imam Mahdi.......... 193

Day Seventh of Zihijjah (Friday) .......... 203

The Debate over Caliphate .......... 203

1- The Difference between the Prophet and the Caliphas .......... 204

2- The Disagreement over the way the Caliphas were Chosen .......... 207

3- The Number of Caliphas after the Prophet .......... 208

Day Eighth of Zihijjah .......... 213

4- The Companions Objection over Ali Not Being Chosen as Calipha .......... 213

Day Ninth of Zihajjah (Arafa Day) .......... 222

The Arafa Supplication .......... 222

Day Eleventh of Zihajjah .......... 224

5- Ali's Superiority over the Other Caliphas .......... 228

Day Fifteenth of Zihajjah .......... 231

6- Consequences over Eliminating Ali from Being Chosen as Calipha after the Prophet .......... 232

Day Sixteenth of Zihajjah .......... 236

7- The Prophet's Testimonial over Ali Being Calipha after Him .......... 237

Day Seventeenth of Zihajjah (Eid Ghadir Night) .......... 244

8- Ghadir Khumm .......... 244

The Prophet's Remark: Whoever I am his Master, Ali is his Master .......... 248

The Companions Remarks after Ali Started as Calipha .......... 264

Why Is the Imam not Mentioned as Calipha In the Quran? .......... 266

Appendix One: Parts of the book of Khasais Ali Ibn Abitaleb .......... 273

Appendix Two: The Book of Virtues of Ali Ibn Abitaleb .......... 298

Introduction .......... 298

The Virtues of Ali .......... 299

Appendix Three: The Complete Speech of Ghadir in Arabic by The Messenger of God .......... 325